A Review of "How to Start or Keep Your Own LCMS Church"
By Rev. William Bischoff

 

Jack Cascione, the Pastor of Redeemer Lutheran Church in St. Clair Shores, Michigan, has written a little book of ONLY 112 pages, but with 198 footnotes carefully documented. [Press release and ordering information.]

This book should be NOT ONLY READ by every pastor and layman in the MO SYNOD, but carefully studied. The title of the book is, HOW TO START OR KEEP YOUR OWN MISSOURI SYNOD LUTHERAN CHURCH. Almighty God through His servant, Hosea, declares, "My people are destroyed through lack of knowledge" (Hosea 4:6), and the Prophet Jeremiah laments, "The prophets prophesy falsely and the priests bear rule by their means, and My people love to have it so, and what will ye do in the end thereof." (Jeremiah 5:31)

We are living today in an age in which technology is advancing and secular knowledge is increasing exponentially on every side. But in the midst of this knowledge explosion the doctrinal erudition of the average person in the local Christian congregation is deteriorating at an alarming rate.

The average church member (even in the LCMS) is "dull of hearing, For when for the time ye ought to be teachers, ye have need that one teach you again which be the first principles of the oracles of God." (Hebrews 5:11,12)

There was once a day when even the average uneducated farmer in the LCMS was so well instructed in the Scriptures and Luther's Small Catechism that he was able to explain and defend not only the doctrines of Baptism and The Lord's Supper, but also the doctrine of Church and Ministry and even Predestination. Every Sunday morning he went to church. In the afternoon he came back for Christenlehre (study of the catechism). In the evening he was back in church for worship. During the week there were daily devotions in his home led by the father of the family. His children were enrolled in the congregation's parochial school where they were further immersed in the Word of God.

The result? Listen to this description of the result in the August 1890 issue of LEHRE AND WEHRE (Doctrine and Defense), "We Missourians then hold a church body as such to be orthodox ONLY when the true doctrine sounds forth from all of its pulpits and professors chairs and in all writings which are published within the church body, and every false doctrine, on the contrary, as soon as it makes its appearance, is eliminated in the way which God directs." Clearly, there was not only UNION in the Missouri Synod but there was also UNITY in doctrine. Sadly, that UNITY no longer exists!

Those of us who grew up in this God-pleasing environment lament the loss of this treasure of pure doctrine (Reine Lehre). But Pastor Jack Cascione is not wasting God's time in just lamenting. By his outspoken witness for the truth in the pages of CHRISTIAN NEWS and wherever else he has the opportunity, he is providing a faithful witness for the TRUTH. His new book is a good example of his on-going witness for the truth.

At first glance, Cascione's book may look like a "HOW TO" manual for lay rebellion within the MO Synod. However, close studies of the contents of the book reveal something quite different.

Both Martin Luther and C.F.W. Walther had no desire to rebel against God's Church or design new doctrines. On the contrary, both of these men desired to be faithful! Not to the teaching of men, but to the teachings of God. It is required in stewards that a man be found faithful." (I Corinthians 4:1-2)

Jack Cascione also desires to be faithful to God. In this book, he demonstrates what God requires of His faithful people. Martin Luther was placed under the ban of the empire because he stood solely on the Word of Go d and refused to bow to commands of the pope or church councils. Walther was called a represtination theologian because he taught and defended the same doctrines Luther taught from the Bible, especially the doctrines of the Priesthood of all Believers and Church and Ministry.

Jack Cascione is under attack today because he is reaffirming the same doctrines Luther and Walter taught from the Bible - The Priesthood of all Believers and the supreme authority of the congregation through the Voters Assembly.

In chapter 29 of his book, Cascione quotes Walter to explain what he seeks to accomplish in this book. Cascione wants every layperson to be a faithful Christian and a genuine member of his or her local congregation.

The three essential requirements to be a genuine Lutheran are:

  1. A thorough understanding of pure Lutheran doctrine or at least a desire to grow in knowledge.
  2. The ability to defend your faith and prove it correct from God's Word.
  3. The ability to distinguish pure doctrine from false doctrine.

When you have finished studying (not just reading) this book, you will be equipped to confess your faith with a clear knowledge and understanding of what the Bible and the true Lutheran Church believes and teaches. If you are a man you will then regularly attend Voters Assembly. You will urge your congregation and its leaders to study the doctrine of Church and Ministry, and you will also urge the Synod in its July Convention to reaffirm the LCMS Biblical position in Church and Ministry.

To further whet your appetite to purchase and study this book, note well the following statements found therein. Each statement is footnoted and documented:

  1. Christ gives supreme and final jurisdiction to the local congregation.
  2. The congregation is above the minister.
  3. The congregation is the final tribunal in church discipline.
  4. The sheep judge their shepherd in all doctrine.
  5. The congregation and not the Synod is "church." Hence, synods are human organizations.
  6. God sends pastors through the instrumentality of men voting.
  7. Even the apostles did not choose a pastor without the congregations vote.
  8. The Bible gives the congregation the right to vote to select their pastor.
  9. Every Christian is a priest of God through Holy Baptism.
  10. There is no other priesthood than that which is possessed by the laity.
  11. There is only an external difference between the laity and the office of the pastor. Before God there is no distinction.
  12. The congregation confers the office of the ministry on a man and this makes him a pastor.
  13. The lay people have authority in respect to Word and Sacrament in the congregation.
  14. The congregation and each member never surrenders their authority.
  15. There is no other priesthood than that which is possessed by the laity.
  16. God's Word is the final authority in the Church.
  17. Ordination has no promise from God nor does it make anyone a pastor in God's eyes.
  18. Ordination is not necessary for the Office of the Ministry.
  19. It is the call of the congregation and not ordination that makes a man a pastor.
  20. Ordination is no more than a human rite by which a man is called into the ministry.

Add this book to your library and you will be on your way to becoming a genuine Lutheran who is both able and willing to confess what you believe!


June 15, 2001